On an all new Roundtable tomorrow, we discuss…
- Alicia Fox as #1 Contender
- Maryse’s return
- The Turning Point card
- Survivor Series Divas match
If you’d like to add your comments & ask a question for the Mailbag, reply with the following:
Name:
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?:
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?:
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?:
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?:
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany (delete as applicable):
Make sure your comment for each topic is no longer than one sentence. Any longer and it will be overlooked.
To take part in the reader survey for each of the topics follow the cut!
[SURVEYS 19]
Posted by 
November 8, 2009 at 4:08 pm
Name: Tom
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: Yes, I love Alicia. The only problem with Alicia is that she can’t get loads of heat. If Alicia had the heat that Jillian gets, Alicia would be a perfect heel diva package.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: If Angelina was still in TNA & TBP I would say yes b’cos then she would have the knockouts title & Velvet & Madison would have the tag belts, but with lacey as the leader, i can’t and don’t want to see her as the top knockout.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: I’m not sure if she will or not, i would prefer her to comeback in a backstage segment with Miz or something like that.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?: I think it will be a 10 diva tag match so i’m saying..
Team Mickie: Mickie, Melina, Gail, Kelly & Eve
Team Michelle: Michelle, Layla, Beth, Natalya & Alicia
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany (delete as applicable): A question for anyone. If you could bring back and 3 former divas, who would you bring back and why?
November 8, 2009 at 4:35 pm
Name: Pedro Pedroso
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: She’s the obvious choice, I just hope WWE takes the little time they have and give her some personality.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: I sure hope not!
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: No idea…
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?: I’m not sure about Mickies team, but McCool should lead the team of Layla, Natalya, Alicia and Jillian.
Question for Melanie: Are you liking Rosas little segments on ECW? How many weeks do you give her before getting released?!
November 8, 2009 at 4:39 pm
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?
Yes, Jillian hasn’t been very good as of late, give her a small break, not from wrestling, but from the title picture. However they should bring her back in it, just not now. Leave Alicia have her push for the title, it’s only fair right?
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?
They better not! Well Madison & Velvet as Tag Champs I won’t mind, but lacey as TNA Champ?! HELL NO! I’ll lose all respect for The Beautiful People if that happens.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?
I think so, if the Team Mickie VS Team McCool is the classic 5 on 5 match, then she could be one of the 5 for McCool’s team. =)
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?
Team Mickie: Mickie James, Melina, Gail Kim, Kelly Kelly ( won’t like =( ) and Eve.
Team McCool: Michelle McCool, Beth Phoenix, Natalya, Layla and (like I said previously) a returning Maryse.
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany (delete as applicable)
I have none right now, sorry. =(
November 8, 2009 at 4:53 pm
I hope it’ll be like this;
Team Mickie: Mickie, Melina, Gail, Eve & Kelly
Team Michelle: Michelle, Beth, Natalya, Alicia/Layla & Maryse/Jillian
November 8, 2009 at 5:39 pm
Name:RKOyou
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?:She’s only heel other then Jillian so it’s not like they have any other choice,Jillian just had her shot so alicia is next in line
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?:
if it was just Madison and Velvet going after the tag titles,then YES but since Lacey is in the match,it’s obvious there not going to win
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?:PROBABLY YES,Michelle will most likely reveal her as a mystery partner and since the opposite side is Team mickie,it gives Maryse her chance at revenge against her
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?:
Team Mickie: Mickie,Maria,Melina,Gail,and Kelly
Team michelle: michelle,Natayla,layla,Beth phoenix,and probably alicia or Jillian(if Melina is on the other team,It could be either one)
This question is hard to answer because we don’t know it’s all the brands or just smackdown,if it’s just smackdown,then they probably will debut some new divas but i doubt it
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany
o you think it’s time to bring up some new divas from FCW because we’ve had divas for many years and it’s kinda getting stale and boring now?
November 8, 2009 at 5:46 pm
Name: Kevin
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: Yes, I think it’s wonderful that she is where she is, again!
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: I would like them to but Lacey seems the one who would be getting the Knockouts title and that would be awful.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: I hope she does, if she does I say she’ll knock Layla off Team McCool.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?:
Team McCool: Michelle, Beth, Layla, Natalya & Alicia
Team James: Mickie, Melina, Kelly, Gail & Eve Torres
Question for Melanie: Tara vs Kong Steel Cage. Thoughts?
November 8, 2009 at 6:41 pm
Name:
Melissa
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?:
I love Alicia, and we’ve seen that Melina & Jillian don’t have the chemistry we’d have hoped… I’m hoping this is Alicia’s first title win in the WWE.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?:
I REALLY REALLY hope not, but I have a feeling this might be their night… *gulp*
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?:
I doubt she’ll return AT Survivor Series, most likely on Raw the next night. If she did return, I think it would be in a backstage segment? Or maybe she’ll help out Team McCool?
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?:
Team James: Mickie James, Melina, Eve Torres, Gail Kim, Kelly Kelly/Maria
Team McCool: Michelle McCool, Beth Phoenix, Natalya, Alicia Fox, Jillian/Layla
November 8, 2009 at 6:47 pm
Name: Shamir
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: I think so because as people have said she;s the only alternative besides i love miss foxxy lol.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: Well it could go either way they do say the third time is the charm although considering lacey’s extreme lack of experience and skill it could be a fatal mistake.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: Maybe, and if she does i guest she’ll be on michelle’s team since this is most likely going to be a face team vs heel team match.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?:
ok it could go like this
team james (mickie, melina, gail, kelly, and eve)
team mccool(michelle, beth, alicia, layla, and jillian), but if the rumors are true then switch jillian out for maryse as the alternative
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany (delete as applicable): this is a little random but i’ll go for it. even though velvet has more “experience” in the wrestling business than the diva search/model girls it seems that women like michelle, layla, alicia, and even eve are better in ring performers but velvet does have far more charisma, personality and mic skills so my question is who is worth more to their company velvet of tna or the diva search/model divas of the wwe.
p.s. i know ive probably wrote more than i should but here’s another question – why dos it seem the wrestlers with charisma and personality are poor in ring wise and wrestlers good in ring wise are insipid and bland(ex: maryse and michelle)
November 8, 2009 at 6:50 pm
Name: Brett aka mr socko
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: Personally I think it is too soon for Alicia to be the number 1 contender. There seems to be a lot of support for her from fans, and while she is promising, I don’t think she is a suitable diva to hold the title at this stage in her career. But given the lack of credible heel opposition on Raw, I guess she is number one contender by default.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: Yes. ODB has (unfortunately) had the most disappointing reign in the history of the knockouts title. This is not her fault, she has been booked very poorly. But I think enough is enough where she’s concerned and that TNA management will chance putting all of the titles on TBP. That can only be good for them.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: I don’t think Maryse will return at Survivor Series, and I really hope she doesn’t. In the past a lot of diva’s have made their returns by simply being thrown in to a multi-diva tag match (e.g ashley, candice, melina). I’d rather the spotlight is entirely on Maryse, maybe by having her do a run-in and attacking Melina on Raw the night after SS.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?: Hard to say, but I think it’ll most likely be Michelle, Layla, Beth, Natalya and Alicia v Mickie, Gail, Kelly, Melina and Eve.
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany (delete as applicable): Is running Diva Dirt your full time jobs or do you do other stuff too?
November 8, 2009 at 7:10 pm
Name: Brandon
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: Unlike Maryse winning the title as a rookie last year after feuding with Michelle for months, Alicia’s character has only won a couple of #1 contenders matches with no story behind them. It should mean something when she wins it and right now its too pointless.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: I hope so or the past month and a half as been a waist of time. I don’t think Lacey winning would kill the championship either. It’s lost credibility over the past few months, so putting it on someone useless will bring meaning back to it when the next title contender goes after her.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: I think she’ll make her return prior to the event, but I believe we’ll see her back in the ring at Survivor Series.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?: I guess it’ll be Mickie, Melina, Kelly Kelly, Gail Kim & Eve vs. Michelle, Maryse, Beth Phoenix, Natalya & Alicia, but there’s no telling at this point.
Question for Tiffany: With rumors of TNA trying to finagle an all Knockouts show, who do you think would be a good choice for the role of an on air commissioner (if they were to have one)?
November 8, 2009 at 7:16 pm
Name: Liam
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?:
I guess so. The fued with Jillian didn’t really pan out aswell with all the botches etc but I suppose Alicia has what it takes to battle it out with the Divas Champ! Melina and Alicia have met before on SD and If I remeber correctly a match has to be edited due to a botch…but theres plenty of room for improvement!
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: I am not sure what to feel on this subject. ODB not the best of champs…If anyone to hold the belt i would like it to be Madison..shes got lots of experience but is just blocked by the less talented Velvet…Lacey well never seen her wrestle properly but im guessing if you could win on looks TBP would win. I think TBP could win just to add a new atmosphere in the Impact Zone.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?:
I hope so. I would love to see the Maryse/Eve/Miz storyline, be great to have different fueds going on instead of having one fued with every diva slowly working their way around the fueds. So hopefully Maryse could be back!
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?:
Im not sure. eother way looks asif Mickies team will be the underdogs. Hopefully be a great match!
November 8, 2009 at 7:24 pm
Name: Gmo Soto
, god! i miss angelina 
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: She is awesome but i dont think she deserves to be champ yet, and wwe can let maryse without a title for long.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: I think they will but i dont like that
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: ACTUALLY SHE IS FLYING SOMEWHERE RIGHT NOW, so maybe we can see her tomorrow
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?: I DONT KNOW WHY THEY PUT MCCOOL VS JAMES TEAM, THAT FEUD DOESNT HAVE A LONG HISTORY YET, I WOULD LOVE TO SEE MCCOOL VS MELINA TEAM in a raw vs scmackdown TRADICIONAL ELIMINATION MATCH… but
mccool: Mccool, Maryse, Layla, Natalya & Alicia
mickie: Mickie, Melina, Gail, Eve & Kelly
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany (delete as applicable): DO you think it is time to some new divas?
November 8, 2009 at 7:36 pm
Name: Katie
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: I think she is the right choice. The Jillian/Melina feud wasn’t very good, so Alicia is the next best thing. I think Melina will retain.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: It would be terrible for TNA to give the titles to the Beautiful People. Lacey is really bad in the ring and hearing all the reports of her backstage antics, why reward her with a title?? I want the champs to retain.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: I don’t know. I could see her being on McCool’s team, but I really think that she will return the night after SS, on RAW.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?:
Team McCool: Michelle, Beth, Layla, Alicia, Jillian or Maryse
Team James: Mickie, Maria, Gail, Melina, Eve or Kelly
November 8, 2009 at 7:39 pm
Name:Chris
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?:Yes,because I love me some foxyness,no,because Melina-Jillian wasn’t given the right chance.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?:I don’t think they will,unless Angelina rejoins them when/if she returns.Besides,TNA isn’t that stupid,I think….
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?:There’s a great chance she will,because she has already stated she might return herself in some interviews recently.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?:Team James:Eve,Maria,Kelly,and Melina
Team McCool:Beth,Natalya,Alica,and Jillian.
Question for All:Do you think the Divas Division will ever return to its former glory?
November 8, 2009 at 7:55 pm
Name: Christopher
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: As of right now, Alicia is the right choice, if you’re going the face/heel routine rout.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: Keeping my personal feelings about this aside, I wouldn’t be surprised if TBP were to hold the gold come Turning Point.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: Probably not in a wrestling role, but I do see her making her return at Survivor Series, possibly helping Team McCool get the win.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?: If it’s 4 on 4, I’m going with McCool, Beth, Layla, and Alicia against Mickie, Melina, Kelly Kelly, and Eve.
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany (delete as applicable): For anyone that can answer: How big do you think the Hogan/Bishoff/TNA relationship will affect the TNA Knockouts, if anything?
November 8, 2009 at 8:06 pm
Name:
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: Out of the current heel divas on Raw, yes, but I’d prefer to see Gail Kim take the role and eventually turn heel in the process.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: No. I like all three of them, but no way is Lacey getting the KO title.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: I pray to god not because there’s already enough bad matches on raw, no need to bring in the overrated queen of 3 moves to make it even worse.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?: Depends how we go, as if Beth is taking on a face role, perhaps Layla, Natalya, and McCool vs. Mickie, Maria, and Beth but with Beth a tweener type.
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany (delete as applicable): Do you think Gail Kim will ever be trusted with another push in WWE after the Mickie incident instead of being the jobber face and first eliminated from battle royals?
November 8, 2009 at 8:06 pm
Name: Bobby*
November 8, 2009 at 8:17 pm
Name:
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: It doesn’t really matter if she is or not because until WWE gives their women character development and storylines the average wrestling fan will continue to be dead during their matches.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: umm..no. but if they don’t who will be the next opponents? t
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: no. if she does it will be in a backstage segment with the miz.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?: James: Kelly, Eve, Gail, Melina McCool: Beth, Layla, Alicia, Natalya
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany (delete as applicable): Tiffany: who would you have as ODB’s next opponent?
November 8, 2009 at 8:49 pm
Name: Bdawg0701
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: YES, Alicia still got the potential to come out as a true contender, despite her HAIC match with Mickie (which was Mickie’s fault, IMO) and with Melina as the champ, BONUS!, because the two can work.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: HELL TO THE NO! I don’t picture Lacey as the Knockouts Champ in the current state she’s in, plus TBP can’t carry matches, except Madison.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: If she cost Team James the match with a deadly French TKO to Mickie out of nowhere, then yes.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?: Team James – Mickie, Melina, Gail, Kelly, and Eve. Team McCool – Michelle, Beth, Natalya, Alicia, and Layla
Question for all: Has there been any updates on Sojo Bolt? She is the only Knockout that hasn’t appear on Impact. What’s her current status?
November 8, 2009 at 9:17 pm
Whoops, I forgot.
Name: Rhys
=P
November 8, 2009 at 10:03 pm
Name: Jacob
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: Yer Totally, she is the future of the divas division even, if i dont see her winning.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: I can see vel/mad being tag champs, but lace as champ is goin too far.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: I have mixed feelings, but i want her too, but i cant really see it happening, but she may do a melina, and return the day after.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?: Michelle,Layla,Beth,Natalya,Alicia vs Mickie,Melina,Kelly,Eve,Gail
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany (delete as applicable): Who do you think will fill out the mickie vs michelle teams, and who will win?
November 8, 2009 at 10:04 pm
Name: Duncan
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: No. Gail Kim should be the next. It’s ridiculous to see title’s changing hands with heels vs faces only. They should all be trying to get the title.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?: I hope so, it would be fun to watch.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: If she does, I hope she receaves a huge crowd reaction
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?: Mickie Gail Melina Beth Eve vs Michelle Layla Jillian Maryse and Natalya
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany (delete as applicable):
November 8, 2009 at 10:34 pm
Name: Evan
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?:
Pretty much, Who else do they have?
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?:
Both the KO & Tag team titles are really stale nowadays so it’s a high possibility. I’m rooting for them.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?:
I don’t think so, Since I’ve been watching WWE (over a year ago) there hasn’t been one triumphant return for a diva at a PPV.
Disclaimer: If there has been then oops
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?:
Shocking.
Layla will be on team McCool, Natalya too probably. That leaves Beth & Maria on team Mickie
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany:
All – What are your thoughts on Wrestlicious?
November 8, 2009 at 11:24 pm
Name: vonVile
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?:
No, the WWE should have stuck it out with Jillian. I fault the WWE’s short sightedness and crappy booking over Melina and Jillian’s botches. Chavo and Hornsoggle entering the mix instantly damned what could have been something interesting and refreshing.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?:
Only if Angelina makes a surprise return at Turning Point.
Like I stated elsewhere, this is Madison’s moment. She can either carry TBP like Angelina always did to a descent match or this will be the official end of the stable.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?:
No, there’s no reason for her to at that point. The WWE should wait until the Raw after, so she can start a feud with Melina.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?:
Another problem created with WWE creative being short sighted when it comes to Divas. McCool has a full team with Layla, Beth and Natalya, but Mickie really has no resources on SD! and has to either go outside her brand or the WWE has to pop 3 new face Divas out of nowhere in the next 2 weeks. Maria could return, but with her on Apprentice that’s unlikely. Team Mickie will most likely be: Mickie, Brie, Nikki and Kelly. A crappy force for sure, but Vince really loves the Bellas at the moment and Kelly is the WWE poster girl.
As for people picking Alicia and Melina, they’ll most likely have their title match at Survivor Series, so they’re out.
November 9, 2009 at 3:57 am
Name: Emerson
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: Yes, because I have a feeling she might just a jobber until another contender is crowned…Possibly Maryse?
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?: No, I don’t think she should because it would be more suitable for her to return during a segment/match strictly involving Melina and her Diva’s Championship .
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?: Mickie,Eve,Gail,Kelly & Melina VS Michelle,Natalya,Beth,Jillian & Alicia
Question for Melanie/Erin/Steven/Tiffany (delete as applicable): All – Do you think the Swagger/Eve storyline is a front to turn Eve heel?
November 9, 2009 at 8:06 am
Name: Tommy
Is Alicia Fox the right choice for Melina’s next challenger?: I think at the moment she is, Jillian and Melina had too many botched matches and Jillian feuding with Melina with I-can’t-beat-a-midget Guerrero would just be stupid. Maryse, although she isn’t very good in the ring would of course be a better option and I’m guessing will be the next Diva’s Champion.
Do you think TBP will take both the Knockouts Title and tag titles?:
Only if TNA Creative is thick as a brick. With Angelina Love in the corner of TBP this match would look amazing but Lacey Von Erich is not ready for a title yet. Her in ring ability sucks worse then Maria or Rosa Mendes.
Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?:
I believe she will and it’ll probably be to disrupt the Diva’s Championship match.
Who do you think will fill out Team James & Team McCool?:
Team James: Mickie James, Maria, Mae Young and debuting Diva – Mia Mancini
Team McCool: Michelle McCool, Beth Pheonix, Natalya and Layla
November 9, 2009 at 9:42 am
1. Is Alicia Fox the right person to face Melina.
I think that this is the logical choice, I think Alicia has proved that she can hold her own, however I would like to see the heat turned up on this fued. Alicia has the potential to be a great heel. WWE need to look back at some of the old divia fueds in the past and start adding that some energy to the current storylines.
2.Do you think that the TBP will take both knockouts and tag titles?:
I hope not. It would be a bit silly for them to win both titles now. I think Velvet and Madison are great, however like so many other people I think Lacey is still green and has been rushed to tv to quickly. TBP at the moment look a hot mess and as beautiful Lacey is, she can’t hold her own just as yet.
3. Will Maryse actually return at Survivor Series?:
Mayrse will return to interfere in the match between Swagger and The Miz. This will lead into a fued between the Miz and Mayrse and Swagger and Eve.
4. Who do you think will fill out Team James and Team McCool ?:
Team James – Mickie James, Melina, Eve and Jenny Cash
Team McCool – Michelle McCool, Beth Phoenix, Natalya and Layla
5. Do you think that the Rhaka Khan (Trenesha) would be hired by another organisation ?
6. Do you think that Jacquline and Ivory would ever go back to wwe? Maybe they could be surprise opponents for Beth?
7.