Comments on: SmackDown Redux (November 20th, 2009): We’re Not in High School Anymore

By: TrishMelinaFan

TrishMelinaFan — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 04:56:45 +0000

OMG!COULD IT BE?The REAL Krissy Vaine has FINALLY posted a comment ere on diva-dirt!Praise the good lord….

By: ReyStyle94

ReyStyle94 — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 03:50:21 +0000

OMG, you are all stupid. Of course it was scripted! JESUS CHRIST! For someone that’s been following wrestling for less than 5 years, I can still remember that wrestling is FAKE! How can people be so stupid? Obviously they told Mickie this would happen, storyline-wise. And why does everyone jump on the idea that pig means fat. We call people pigs when they are sloppy and disgusting. Why must pig mean fat?

By: Krissy Vaine

Krissy Vaine — Sun, 22 Nov 2009 01:38:43 +0000

Ridiculous and cruel…. FYI I feel sure those tears were not scripted as those words were real and stabbing. Disgusting

By: Armando

Armando — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 20:42:02 +0000

I love how all of you are saying how stupid my comments were and how stupid I made myself look, but all of you are stupid for still taking the time to reply to my comments. I obviously hit a nerve with all you Mickie fans. I love this website and it’s members. Don’t change Diva-Dirt.

By: spiffy

spiffy — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 20:21:22 +0000

What made the segment worse (or funniest) is that as Mickie’s walking up the the ramp in tears, the camera follows her, trying to get the crowd to sympathize. All of a sudden…….cut to Rey Mysterio backstage, and the crowd erupts in cheer. Totally brushing off the emotional Mickie segment. Props to Mickie for crying on cue though.

By: The Crying Light

The Crying Light — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 17:31:56 +0000

People, it’s obvious that ARMANDO is merely trying to get our attention. Seriously. His statements for one are poorly founded, he obviously needs to learn how to use a dictionary as showcased in comment 54 among others and his responses are merely childish retorts that are of no consequence. Let’s move on. He may not have noticed but his previous statements just proves how poor his logic is. Besides, I don’t think there is anything he can say that can redeem himself from such stupidity. =) I love it when people shoot themselves on the feet.

By: TrishMelinaFan

TrishMelinaFan — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 16:33:07 +0000

Armando-Ya know,you can stop adding repeated comments now.I don’t agree with your comments,but hello,they’re YOUR comments,and you have a right to your opinion as does everyone else,no need for everybody to get caddy with each other.

By: Armando

Armando — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 07:05:56 +0000

Stay classy, SAPPHIRE

By: vonVile

vonVile — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 06:53:02 +0000

If Mickie James was officially hurt she should ‘no show’ at Survivor Series. When the WWE calls her up she can claim that she was too fat to get through her hotel door that morning.

By: Jim Molloy

Jim Molloy — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 06:48:41 +0000

Melanie, I agree with your analysis 100%. What in hell is going on with the writers at WWE. That segment with Mickey James on national television was disgusting. Competative matches only is what they need to market. I hope that they do not screw up the return of Maryse. I think that TNA allows their Divas to have competative matches without the side bar trivia. I have always been a loyal fan, but it is time to get back to competative wrestling. The writers are coming across as real amateurs.

By: Sapphire

Sapphire — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 06:41:31 +0000

After the comments you made earlier, you are in no position to tell others to stay classy, Armando.

By: SheamusNoKoibito

SheamusNoKoibito — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 06:39:58 +0000

I think Mickie’s inaction is an indication that they are building up to something really big. And such a thing like what happened wouldn’t bother me at all if I was a 100% sure that it didn’t have grains of truth in it. WWE is known for it, so that’s all that bothers me. And taking it as a storyline, it’s immature but it does give more attention to the Divas, but my worry is the “fans” who are so easily swayed by stuff like that as to start taking up the charge of chanting “Piggy James” and bringing signs making fun of her weight. Because not everybody likes Mickie James, and like somebody said, some people just love to hate; they pick something and go with it. It would suck to end one’s career on an anticlimax/”stigma” like that. It’s the “fans” reaction I don’t trust. Mickie’ll bounce back, I’m sure! And if anything, when people mention eating disorders, I think about the girls who decide to stop watching WWE RIGHT AFTER something like what happens and don’t wait around to see the conclusion/revenge/comeback, leaving w/a sour taste in their mouths.

By: Armando

Armando — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 06:23:17 +0000

Mizchick, no I will not like Mickie if she lost a few pounds. I used to love her when she first debuted in WWE, but I feel like in my eyes she lost her sparkle. I give her credit for being an astounding performer and being able to hold the Divas and Woman’s belt in her career, but with how WWE uses her on television doesn’t make me want to like her anymore. So no I wont like her if she lost weight. Her fire has been put out in my eyes.

Lol I won’t say what I got to say on Mickie James anymore. You Mickie stans are delusional. I’ll let you guys have your moment. Send WWE letters of outrage! Stay Classy Mickie fans

By: The Crying Light

The Crying Light — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 06:10:53 +0000

This storyline is weak. That is the real issue here. While the men mostly feud about more serious matters, the WWE “creative” team are having the women squabble over petty reasons like this. It was somewhat smirk-worthy to a very diminutive degree but overall, it was childish, pathetic and dare I say, insulting.

The WWE is supposed to be the biggest pro-wrestling promotion in the world. In that sense, they are tied to the identity of this form of entertainment and whether you like it or not, they have the responsibility of representing its milieu. What a shame that this is the way this “number one” company views women.

But really, how can we blame them when we have infantile viewers enjoying this something this stupid. They are, after all, what fuels the machine. =)

By: xx_swayme

xx_swayme — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 05:22:08 +0000

LOL @ all the soap box preaching.. Get over it.. Mickie could honestly care less what this site, the editors, or posters think abot her weight.. She is sitting there collecting money that none of us probably will never see while you all cry over a storyline that has finally come to the Divas.. Makes me wonder how old some of you are, or how serious you really take this.. Don’t the TBP hurl far worse insults at their fellow Knockouts?.. Oh wait, that’s TNA and they are PG-13 so it’s allowed there I guess.. Give me a break. LOL

I really do enjoy Michelle & Layla as they are both becoming the type you love to hate. I highly doubt that Michelle’s team will win this Sunday after they got the last laugh on SmackDown, but hopefully this continues; it’s refreshing.

By: Marco

Marco — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 05:09:43 +0000

XDDDD You peeps are officially making my night!
Lulz, I love everyone here being all like “OMG WTF WHY IS WWE SO CRUEL OMG OMG OMG AHHHH GO TO TNA MICKIE PLZ GO TO TNA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!”
Srsly everyone, it’s a storyline, even if they are poking fun at Mickie, still it’s a storyline. Like really, you people take this shit so seriously, it makes me laugh :)

As for what I thought, the segment was great! Mickie is doing sum fine ass acting there, she really looked like she was hurt by the piece. Even if that thing was immature and stereotypically mean girl, it still made me laugh…
Round of applause to creative, at least they are finally giving a crap enough about one diva division to give it a storyline with an actual back-story!

By: Mr.Glamazon

Mr.Glamazon — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 05:04:25 +0000

The debates here are funny…I esp like how people think the WWE is mistreating Mickie…she is a FOUR time women’s champ and a Divas champ and has had a great career. The sketch tonight wasn’t the best thing they have ever done, but at least they are telling a story (maybe not your favorite) and giving the girls some air time. I prefer seeing Michelle in a farmer’s outfit more than seeing that stupid R-Truth come down and ruin another brilliant CM Punk promo…gessshhh, talk about amatuer hour. “What’s Up! The Truth! And the truth is I don’t like you!” Thanks R-Truth.

I also think it is funny when people say Mickie (or wrestler “x”) should quit WWE and go to TNA. People love telling others what they should do. Mickie’s paycheck is prob sweet and she is a hero to kids all over the world. That’s a bad gig?? Whether we / they always like the storylines or not, every wrestler wants to reach the top of their profession and being employeed by WWE is the major leagues compared to TNA. All the stars that leave WWE and then bad-mouth the company all come across as bitter (yeah, like WWE really misses Ken Kennedy). I’d love to see how many TNA “stars” would say “no” to a call from Vince. God the thought of watching a federation that still employs Scott Steiner and Kevin Nash (and soon Hogan LOL!) makes me cringe. Talk about stale.

By: chrisP

chrisP — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 05:00:57 +0000

Did anyone notice Striker and Grisham saying at the very end that Michelle was pretty funny after they first sold it as mean a few seconds eariler? Maybe WWE is going to play this for laughs.

By: Nemesis

Nemesis — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 04:39:49 +0000

That wasn’t right. Tasteless. She looked legitimately hurt.

By: Sapphire

Sapphire — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 03:32:55 +0000

Guys, it’s basically useless challenging Armando’s posts when he suggests something so nonsensical like Mickie defying creative’s orders and putting her own career in jeapordy. That just suggests he doesn’t have a clue.

Onto SmackDown.. while I do appreciate the fact that they’re doing something storyline-wise FINALLY for the Divas, I just can’t get behind this particular storyline because it’s so grade school-ish. That’s just how I feel. I would literally be embarrassed if I was watching this with the family or a few friends tbh. But that’s the problem with the WWE as a whole, it’s all directed towards the kiddies now. Ehh. Layla’s pretty good on the mic though imo, I guess that’s something positive to take out of this.

*crosses fingers for Survivor Series* I hope it’s as good as last year’s, or is that asking too much at this point? Maybe I should expect a train wreck and be pleasantly surprised. -.-

By: Mizchick

Mizchick — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 03:04:04 +0000

So lol you’re mad because physco Mickie is gone?,woow if you were a fan then why not now?,that just shows how great of a fan you are,how can someone who sounds so smart be so immature?…..oh Armando not trying to starts something here just saying what if Mickie loses some pounds will you like her again?,hmm just saying!.

By: Mizchick

Mizchick — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 02:51:07 +0000

and BTW is not funny anymore when you see someone cry like that!!!.

By: Mizchick

Mizchick — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 02:48:54 +0000

I’m soo pissed I can’t believe wwe allows this to happen,I just saw the match here in my house still watching Sd and I just can’t believe they went soo low to the point where a persons feelings got hurt,scripted or not,that was really really mean and I’ve watched wwe for years and I just can’t believe a 4 time women’s and 1 time Diva’s champion gets treated that way,I like Michelle and Layla but that had nothing to do with wrestling is not their business if Mickie is fat or not,which to me she’s not but to wwe ok she needs to pull it together and lose some weight,but she’s beautiful and talented but of course that job requires the superstars to stay fit but it wasn’t necessary seriously….I guess that’s wwe now,but I think it was up to Michelle and Layla,Mickie got embarrased in front of Millions of people! they crossed the line,but well I guess that’s wwe!…but again scripted or not that was really really mean!.

By: Armando

Armando — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 02:45:54 +0000

Lol .MCH That’s the best you got. Don’t worry about my life, worry about your Piggy Mickie James.

By: .MCH

.MCH — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 02:25:04 +0000

You should take your own advice Armando.

By: mva85

mva85 — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 02:22:12 +0000

The Segment was very funny lol

By: Armando

Armando — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 02:04:35 +0000

Maybe instead of replying to me all you guys should be sending Piggy James some packages filled with Nutrisystem, Jenny Craig, and all kinds of weight losing brochures as well as some diet pills. People need to lighten up not everyone is going to be all up Mickie James’ ass and praise her. I liked psycho Mickie, so until that one returns this “mickie” that WWE has been shoving down our throats is boring and fat and should reconsider a personal trainer. GTFO if you can’t handle other peoples comments.

By: Goodnightddtmnm

Goodnightddtmnm — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 01:58:07 +0000

Mikas-Dude u r like my best friend here on Diva-Dirt LOL that is exactly what im talking about ppl on here who was calling mickie fat and overrtated and stuff r now jumping to her defense…smh…

I thought the match was good btw…they both did great…

Mickie is my favorite Diva of course..I know she isnt Fat so I dont get offended when they call her fat or make fun of weight , Mickie is a beautiful , skillfull and talented young women. Yeah WWE may be making fun of her or maybe they arent who knows and who cares. If she was just to leave wwe for weight issues …they will be the ones begging her and offering her all this money in the next 6yrs when they need her again…or when she is in TNA.

By: mpezza

mpezza — Sat, 21 Nov 2009 00:57:27 +0000

I found it hilarious. People need to lighten up.

By: dal

dal — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 22:53:42 +0000

GGRRRR the segment with manchelle was a really tasteless way to further the mickie michelle/layla fued

By: Mikas

Mikas — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 22:45:45 +0000

Funny how some of the divadirt readers that used to call Mickie “fat” are now furious about how she is made fun off. Guess some people just look for excuses to hate.

But based on the reactions this story has already generated in a few days time, you can only draw 1 conclusion: Michelle is becoming a great heel, just as they planned it. And this is the first time in 2009 that people actually care about Mickie James. So i take my hat off for the creative team, they are doing an excellent job.

By: thedream

thedream — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 22:31:52 +0000

after seeing this i kind of get the feeling mickie will be retiring very soon. reminds me of how lita left almost, and all the references of mickie being “one of the best divas ever”. that might explain why they are pushing melina and possibly beth into those slots. i predict mickie will win the woman’s title in her final match against michelle very soon. and then beth phoenix will fill the top face slot on smackdown

By: KrissyVaineLurver

KrissyVaineLurver — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 22:22:27 +0000

gtfo armando. Internet heel games = fail and not funny. James is hot, and while I found the segment to be great, your comments were stupid and unfunny just like your probably are.

By: THETommyTommy

THETommyTommy — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 22:18:29 +0000

If those weren’t real tears she had me convinced. I actually found the segment insulting and I wasn’t even on the receiving end. Layla has improved a lot in the ring I must say I really hope they’re doing this to give Mickie a push towards a fifth woman’s championship reign and not just doing it to bully her. :(

By: xx4xl3tt3rxli3xx

xx4xl3tt3rxli3xx — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 22:18:00 +0000

i honestly don’t see the big deal. atleast they acually care enough about smackdown divas to give them an acual storylinee. if you think about it that way the segments kind of geniusee. but mickie just crying is stupidd. she should get pissed and chase layla away or somethingg. oh&& did anyone notice how good mickie looked this weekk. much better then last week. she always looks like a dirtbag when she wears that blue ring attire she wore last weekk.

By: TrishMelinaFan

TrishMelinaFan — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 22:17:00 +0000

Well first of all,I expected the match to be a little longer,but no.It was good for what it was.Not gonna lie,I laughed at the whole Michelle segment,but looking back on it,t is a bit cruel.This weeks Smackdown was sad,and I think Mickie was crying FOR REAL!If not,she’s a damn good actress.

Armando-WTF?What you said was just cruel,and I see nothing wrong with Mickie’s weight.It’s people like you that corrupt people’s minds.

P.S.I liked Layla’s outfit this week.

By: theregoeskitty

theregoeskitty — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 22:10:33 +0000

eew did layla take fashion tips from maria this week?

the match was ok shame it was over quick, but i liked the ending,

poor mickey that segment was lame

By: afca

afca — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 20:54:58 +0000

RKOyou: does that really make a difference, if its reading nasty things about yourself on the internet or being humilated on tv to me feels like the same thing, both feelings are hurt

but lets keep it at that ]shall we? you do have a valid point, but as a fan of mccool i see it from another side.

By: RKOyou

RKOyou — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 20:44:59 +0000

afca-I don’t see Michelle ever getting humilated on TV,when she does,then we’ll talk

By: chrisP

chrisP — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 20:44:20 +0000

The offensive thing about this storyline is not treating Mickie James badly but how stupid the whole thing is. The stupidity of it is what I don’t like. It really sucks that WWE Divas these days either have no storylines or storylines that are terrible and lame.

By: adifferentsame

adifferentsame — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 20:42:30 +0000

By the way, Layla was excellent here. She’ll never transcend jobber status, probably, but she does a nice job playing the snivelling villainess and her mic work has always been underrated. I hope she gets breathing space in the Survivor Series match, rather than be fodder to make Eve or Kelly Kelly look good.

By: purplehaze

purplehaze — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 20:33:29 +0000

The whole skit was lame the funniest thing about it was Michelle’s “singing”. Seriously I’m all for a Michelle and Mickie feuding but these are grown women having Michelle and Layla coming out every week teasing Mickie and her running away crying is just silly.

By: afca

afca — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 20:31:19 +0000

@ RKOyou:

‘wrestlers are human beings also’

& that coming from one of the biggest mccool haters ever, you have said the nastiest things about her so thats pretty hypocritical of you.

By: adifferentsame

adifferentsame — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 20:26:02 +0000

I imagine someone with the mentality of Armando submitted the script for this shit angle we’re seeing on Smackdown.

By: RKOyou

RKOyou — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 20:22:10 +0000

Armando-Mickie was in TNA back in 2002,when there was NO womens division and when TNA did suck,now it’s awesome,you better recognize.Your saying mickie should lose some weight or WWE should fire,someone should fire you for commenting like that,it’s people like you that make big girls feel inferior to the skinny girls,mickie should not change the way she looks to satisfy people like you who obviously don’t have a heart

It’s not whats on the outside,it’s whats on the inside and mickie is beautiful inside and out and I hope she isn’t sad for real but who could blame her after going through this,wrestlers are human beings also,it’s not all in the script

By: Ana_Nattie_rules

Ana_Nattie_rules — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 20:17:22 +0000

Armando – OMG, that was so, but so rude.

Are you out of your mind? Comparing Mickie…to Cherry? WHAT??? Its like comparing Maria to Lita or Trish.
Im not going to tell what I think about your comments on her weight, seriously. But you know, in the WWE and in TNA there’s something called SCRIPT. And when you jump script, unless you are a big superstar like Batista (he and Booker T had some real life issues) you probably get fired. But Mickie James is a PROFESSIONAL and she does what she is supposed to do. Just like Michelle.
Everyone is talking how bad this is to Mickie, but look at Michelle. She is a former teacher who’s making a fool out of herself and still she does it. Those girls are professionals. They aren’t going to leave a company because of a stupid storyline.

By: darkmarvel

darkmarvel — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 20:10:09 +0000

The Mickie James/Michelle McCool saga continues with another display of what Melanie calls ” juvenile school pranks” its kindly making their smackdown diva segments now worth watching to see how Michelle McCool and Layla gonna make Mickie James’ life hell week after week. Right now, its like Melanie said, its all high school, but when we were in high school we saw these kind of people bullying others and we all wanted payback for that bully. I think its gonna make the conclusion of the James/McCool interesting when they finally get into the ring one on one and everybody is cheering on Mickie because at the end of the day, no one likes a bully.

By: Armando

Armando — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 20:08:41 +0000

RKOyou- She was already in TNA and that didn’t do her any justice. It was just as bad as TNA is now.

The match was short but whatever I loved Layla and thought she handled it perfectly. Mickie on the other hand needs to lose some weight. WWE should fire her like they did with Cherry. The segment with Michelle was funny and I hate Michelle McFool so for that to entertain me is surprising. Mickie though you are a good competitor but crying instead of getting your revenge is retarded. It’s making you look like Kelly Kelly when she debuted and couldn’t unhook her bra. You are losing your sparkle. Maybe you need some Edward Cullen in your life to be dazzled. Stop crying you cry baby and go get revenge. Fuck what the writers write for you. They only make you look like a talentless pig. So Mickie lose some weight and then you’ll be holding that Woman’s Championship around your waist, because the only reason you aren’t champion right now is because it doesn’t buckle when you put it on your waist. Take it from WWE and lose some weight girl.

By: RKOyou

RKOyou — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 19:45:57 +0000

OMG I love you so much mickie,your not fat at all,your beautiful and way better looking then that stick michelle

I really hate michelle,i don’t care if it’s scripted,it’s all tied together with mickies real life weight gain,it was PERSONAL and my heart goes out to mickie,I would also be upset if the whole world saw my face on a pig.For all the people who never noticed mickies weight before,they will notice now and that makes me mad

Mickie LEAVE WWE and come to TNA,TNA will threat you right unlike the disgrace that is WWE creative

By: KrissyVaineLurver

KrissyVaineLurver — Fri, 20 Nov 2009 19:29:25 +0000

Michelle = Amazing. Died of laughter through it all and loved it more than any divas segment since mickie/trish