PWI Female 50 2011 Revealed

This year’s Pro Wrestling Illustrated Female 50 list has finally been revealed!

The magazine is due to go on sale later this month, but LordsofPain.net has obtained a copy.

Earlier this week, it was reported that SHIMMER Champion, Madison Eagles, had claimed the top spot, but now you can see who else scored big.

Speaking on the list, PWI revealed how they chose who to represent them with the main spot: “This year’s list was unlike any other in the four-year history of the Female 50. For one thing, there was no obvious frontrunner in either WWE or TNA. Last year’s number one, Michelle McCool, retired after a few lackluster months. The WWE Divas title dropped in prominence and was held for a significant amount of time by Brie Bella who, while improved, doesn’t exactly conjure thoughts of Sensational Sherri or Trish Stratus.”

“So we made a bold decision. We looked to the indies. Two possible candidates were SHIMMER champion Madison Eagles and WSU champion Mercedes Martinez. It was a difficult choice to make,” the magazine explains. “Fortunately for us, Martinez and Eagles faced off in March for Eagles’ SHIMMER title. Eagles managed to win a terrific match, which proved to be the deciding factor in our decision.”

“While being on WWE’s or TNA’s global platform helps your chances, it doesn’t mean you get a free passage onto the Female 50.”

Check out the list below:

1. Madison Eagles
2. Mercedes Martinez
3. Mickie James
4. Natalya
5. Madison Rayne
6. Cheerleader Melissa
7. Beth Phoenix
8. Tara
9. MsChif
10. Sara Del Rey
11. Eve Torres
12. Angelina Love
13. Layla
14. Sarita
15. Kelly Kelly
16. Serena Deeb
17. Velvet Sky
18. Ayako Hamada
19. LuFisto
20. Winter
21. Brie Bella
22. Angel Orsini
23. Melina
24. Daizee Haze
25. Nikki Roxx
26. Gail Kim
27. Jazz
28. Maryse
29. Christina Von Eerie
30. Portia Perez
31. Rosita
32. ODB
33. Nicole Matthews
34. Rachel Summerlyn
35. Jessicka Havok
36. Brittany Force
37. Kellie Skater
38. Tina San Antonio
39. Melanie Cruise
40. Cherry Bomb
41. Sassy Stephie
42. Tasha Simone
43. Alicia Fox
44. Amber O’Neal
45. Allison Danger
46. Kacee Carlisle
47. Brittany Savage
48. A.J.
49. Melissa Coates
50. Jessica James

The PWI Female 50 list will be featured in the November issue of Pro Wrestling Illustrated. You can purchase the issue at this link. PWI is offering a special offer for online customers giving you $4 off the retail price — that’s $5.95, down from the usual $9.95.

NXT Reviewer - Read Profile
  • Kaitlyn1fan

    Where the hell is Kaitlyn?!?! She’s the best wrestler there, honestly these “wrestlers” need to learn from Kaitlyn seriously, then you’d be the best. Not even in the top ten, this SUCKS!

    • NaomiNightfan2011

      O.o Please tell me this is a joke……..

    • laqisha

      you are so dumb for sure……have you seen madison eagels work???

      • Kaitlyn1fan

        You’re dumb! Kaitlyn is amazing so stop hating on her, okay?!

        • laqisha

          you have some issues……please go get yourself some help.

        • Kaitlyn1fan

          You need help if you think Madison is the best wrestler in the world.

      • Kaitlyn1fan

        You’re a sheep, seriously.

    • A.E

      someone tell me he/she is kidding or making an early april fools joke

      • Lita-Sault-666

        The Kaitlyn remark has to be a joke. I understand having your own opinion, and that we all have our favourites, but to state that she’s the best wrestler ever with just over a years experience is ridiculous. Kaitlyn wouldn’t ave made my list neither.

        …& to say that the others could learn from her, that’s an insult to Womens Wrestling. Heck, that’s an insult to stink faces & booty pops!

        • Kaitlyn1fan

          I’m not allowed an opinion? She is the best women’s wrestler of all time!

      • Kaitlyn1fan

        No, it’s not a joke.

    • shannymac

      Don’t feed the troll.

      • Kaitlyn1fan

        I am not a troll.

        • WWFoverWWE

          kaitlyn sucks, my butt has more talent than her

        • A.E

          WWFoverWWE lol good one

    • LadyGoDiva

      The list basically tallys up all the female wrestlers in see how activate they are and how hard working they are.

      I do think that Katilyn not being on the list is sad despite that AJ is on th list in which I’m happy to see but I thinnk I want to see more from Katilyn so that later on we’ll see her on the list.

    • Lu Pone

      YES! I definitely agree with KAITLYN1FAN!

      Kaitlyn is the best wrestler LIKE EVER. She should be number one because her in ring movement is LACKLUSTER, she’s NOT as crisp and convincing as Natalya, her strength is nothing compared to Beth Phoenix or Cheerleader Melissa for that matter, her athleticism has yet to manifest as actively as Gail Kim, and her commitment to her character is NOTHING compared to MsChif (if Kaitlyn even has a solid character to begin with.)

      YES! Kaitlyn is THE BEST! As a Kaitlyn fan, THIS IS A FACT! And like KAITLYN1FAN, I will present this as a fact! And if you call me out on it, I will call this my opinion… because that’s the way the world works! You people are, LIKE, sheep!

      • Raekon

        Sarcasm here on there, you are very wrong when it comes to kaitlyns strength cause believe it or not she is indeed the strongest divas in the division right now.

        She can lift 300 pounds while Beth has problems to lift eve or other big girls for the glam slam. Kaitlyn has the strenght advantage due to her bodybuilding time and she would be even stronger than she already is if wwe wouldn’t ask her to lose muscles so she can look more diva like.

        As about the list I agree that she shouldn’t be in the top 50 yet and Maryse shouldn’t be in it either.

        Kelly, Eve or the Bellas been higher on the list than Gail or Melina is laughable to say the least.

      • laqisha

        Your totally failing at playing “the diva super fan” character here at dd…..like do you even know a typical diva dirts reader dosn’t even know who’s mschif or cheerleader melissa is??? and yes I’m talking to you ppl with kelly’s gravatars, or eve’s gravatarz. Hello where you’ve been.

        • BillyGP

          I like Kelly but i know who Melissa and MSchif is.

        • laqisha

          well i already knew that your familiar with melissa due to her tna days but i have no clue you know mschif or even shimmer.

      • Kaitlyn1fan

        Finally somebody with sense than these sheep!!

    • davepower

      Laughable discussion kayfabe or otherwise

      • http://au.groups.yahoo.com/group/WWE_Divas/ art

        Kaitlyn legs presses 300 pounds not lifts it…id like to see if Kaitlyn could miliary press eve or kelly….

        @Lu Pone made my day LOL…

        • davepower

          SERIOUS
          WRESTLING
          DISCUSSION

  • VelvetLoveFan

    Velvet 17? She should be atleast Top 10, IMO!

    • http://twitter.com/tjei012 TJÉ TC

      No way! She has the charisma but she’s like Kelly in the ring!

      • A.E

        dude you just crack me up she atleast trying to look strong velvet aint the best in the ring but she is ok unlike kelly kelly who isn’t even trying to look strong in the ring and even her move is weak huh what move but slap and stinkface.

        • http://twitter.com/tjei012 TJÉ TC

          @ A.E… it’s more bout the storyline you know… And I actually think that K2’s trying like all other ladies out there.
          @LU PONE, IKR!

      • VelvetLoveFan

        Velvet Is way better than Kelly, yeah she not #1 but she isn’t a 17 like I said IMO! My opinion!

        • Lu Pone

          Of course NOT! Kelly is better than Velvet! Velvet can’t do the supremely athletic, overtly epic and extremely exciting move of wiping your behind on your opponents face! She can only do it on the second rope.

  • http://Twitter.com/Just_Trevon Flybytre

    This Is Good Do I Agree No But Still Good List Considered It’s Based On KayFabe accomplishments.and not wrestling skill.

    I Know Michelle McCool Retired In May But I Did Thought She’s Be On The List. She Can Be My Honorary #51

    • http://twitter.com/tjei012 TJÉ TC

      I totally agree!
      what about Snooki! LMAO she had a match at wrestlemania! just sayin!

    • http://www.diva-fiva.com samtherofl

      Mine too.

  • http://ashmultimedia.wordpress.com melon2617

    How is Brie on there but not Nikki? They awarded Michelle #1 based on that stupid “co-champion” rule (even though LAYLA was women’s champ) so wouldn’t the same rule apply to Nikki? Layla has been inactive since Michelle retired so she should be much lower or off the list completely.

    • http://www.diva-fiva.com samtherofl

      McCool’s number one spot was NOT based on the co-champion rule. McCool became the first woman to capture the diva’s championship/women’s championship in 2009 of August, That is why she was number 1.

    • http://www.diva-fiva.com samtherofl

      Something doesn’t make sense here… Michelle McCool isn’t on the list yet Layla is? McCool done as much as Layla if not more. She unified the titles.. It’s confusing.. McCool/Layla have both not wrestled since May.

  • divafandom

    Before ppl go crazy this is not ranked on talent…

    • http://twitter.com/tjei012 TJÉ TC

      Then what is this ranking based on?

      • laqisha

        wrestling ability, accomplishments during the past year, physical strength and conditioning, quality of opposition, charisma, and title success.”

        • http://ashmultimedia.wordpress.com melon2617

          See, it’s the accomplishments of the last year part that throws me.

          Last year, Michelle “helping” Layla defend Layla’s Women’s championship was criteria for her being number one, despite her not being recognized as the actual women’s champion on camera (The storyline was Teddy Long trying to get them to admit there could only be one champ & wwe.com recognized only Layla as champ) but leave Nikki off the list despite her being in the same sitch & appearing every week, while Gail & Melina were rarely on camera. Same with Beth. She was mainly in random tag matches followed by periods of inactivity. If you want to go by the last 12 months, then yes, Kelly, Eve, & the Bellas should be higher than Melina,Gail, Beth & Layla, who has been inactive for months x

        • BillyGP

          Melon2617 how does that make Michelle #1? Yes not he list but not #1.

  • FrankNFurter

    Tragic that Naomi didn’t make the list this year but AJ barely makes it this year. Congrats to her.

    No Michelle McCool, suprpised much.

    • FrankNFurter

      *surprised*

    • davepower

      Tragic?

      Do you understand the list?

      • Rhawk

        More like ‘Tragic?’ That’s the word to use? I sa its dissapointing, but NOWHERE near tragic. People dying from cancer is ‘tragic’, not Naomi missing out on the PWI Top 50, even though I think she should have made the list as well.

      • FrankNFurter

        By tragic I did mean disappointing so please disregard the different meanings, I suppose it’s a Chicago thing.

        And yes, I completely understand the list. I was informed by a poster that FCW was looked at as well and Naomi has surely done some noteworthy things during the time the list was based.

  • http://youtube.com/stephenpeppard stephenpwwe

    Happy that Beth and Natalya are the only current Diva’s in the top 10. Jazz should have been higher and Alicia should have at least been in the 20’s. Madison Eagles deserved number 1, and happy Layla is higher then Kelly :)

    • davepower

      Why should Jazz be higher what has she accomplished this year?

      • http://youtube.com/stephenpeppard stephenpwwe

        What has Velvet Sky accomplished this year ? same difference.

        • davepower

          Wrestled more than a handful of matches

        • BillyGP

          what has Velvet done? She been in feuds. won matches,is very over, plus who she wrestled helps.

  • JACKBLACK

    Alicia Fox should be up there with Eve and don’t get why Beth is so high kayfabe wise she hasn’t no shit all year.

  • Mikas

    The top10 looks very good this year, if you go pure by kayfabe and ignore skills.
    The only person i kinda disagree with is Beth Phoenix, she wasnt used on tv for most of the past 12 months. And I did expect Kelly to be in the top10, but they probably didnt include her title reign which is still very fresh.

    #15 to #50 look kinda random. Ayako Hamada has only wrestled a few matches in Japan and Mexico and 2 shimmer tapings, i dont think thats enough to be #18.
    And a big name that is missing is Hailey Hatred, she is the JWP champion, the oldest womens title in existence right now. Kinda sad they left her off the list. But other than that i cant really complain about the list.

    • laqisha

      its depressing how hailey and the four joshies from shimmer didn’t make the list.

    • Bdawg0701

      I happy Rachel and Jessica made the list. I’m bumbed Athena didn’t make the list. But I think pwi don’t watch japan products for joshi stars not in the list.

  • Lily

    This list is alright. The top 3 makes sense, the rest not so much.

  • Lily

    The first two comments are so annoying, oh god marks are so irritating.

    • BillyGP

      then your annoying LOL (joke) but really nothing wrong with velvet she a decent wrestler.

      • WWFoverWWE

        I think kelly should take notes from velvet on how to play her character better. velvet plays the role better

        • http://twitter.com/tjei012 TJÉ TC

          I think K2 did great during her feud with LayCool and Vickie, and when she had an alliance with Beth and Tiffany.

    • VelvetLoveFan

      I said IMO not yours…. Mine! Don’t hate!! Thank You!

    • Lu Pone

      @LILY: The first two comments are so annoying, oh god marks are so irritating

      UGH! HOW DARE YOU INSULT MARKS! If not for marks, how else would people like you know that you’re not visually impaired? Do you know how much talent it takes for a mark to make people like you feel sane, superior, and logical? Do you know how much MR. ASSTASTIC, KAITLYN1FAN and VALESE works to make sure that reality is bent in their perception in order to be convincing blind people? Shame on you!

      That’s it, I’m going to start a union for marks and we will sue you for emotional distress! They’ll have to repossess that “Y” on your username to denote how much money you’ll have left after the lawsuit is over and done!

      Diva-ness for LIFE!!!

      • davepower

        Wut

    • Kaitlyn1fan

      Not as annoying as Naomi’s mic skills she has NOTHING on Kaitlyn.

    • LayCoolAddict

      Kelly Kelly marks are the most annoying xd but i agree the top comment is stupid

  • Mikas

    I count 25 names that worked for Shimmer, 50% is not a bad score ;-)

  • MaryseAddict

    I’m a Maryse fan, but she hasn’t done nothing this year to be on the list, except for slapping people on NXT.

    • http://ashmultimedia.wordpress.com melon2617

      Agreed. I love Maryse but besides taking an implant buster from Kharma, she’s barely been used. I’ve seen the same comments about Beth.

      Much like the PWI 500, it’s gonna take some time to iron out the selection process. Madison Rayne became the longest reigning KO champ, which should rank her higher than Mickie. Beth likely should be lower as she has only recently entered the Diva picture & was off camera for weeks on end. Same with Melina. Love her but she was inactive for weeks while Alicia was on camera regularily. The list is allegedly a kayfabe list of what women accomplished the most in 12 months. This is more a slapdash “oh we like her, let’s put her here” sort of deal.

      • mickiezDragon

        But if you count “accomplishments, even though Madison had the longest reign, Mickie became the first Triple Crown and only 8 time Champion, which should explain why she ranks higher…

        • http://ashmultimedia.wordpress.com melon2617

          But her eigth reign started last week. It takes most magazines 2 months to be put together so she would have been champion for a couple of months when this list was compiled. Rayne spent 6 months of the last 12 as KO champion, which in kayfabe terms would elevate her higher than Mickie. Either way, this list is rather random. Beth being higher than Divas who are working every week seems a little odd, but Meh. 

        • BillyGP

          Really? I do think Madison should of been 2-4 but Mickie did become the first triple crown champion in APRIL and remember she wrestles outside TNA also and even won a title outside TNA plus a 4 month reign not bad specially in TNA,

  • IronSheikFan

    No Alicia or Rain but Brittney Force, Melissa Coates and Tina San Antonio? Seems fishy.

    • laqisha

      i don’t understand why they left out athena, mia yim, amy lee, haiely hatred, leva bates and jamilia craft.

      • davepower

        As there is only 50 spots

        • laqisha

          guess what….. i can name few talent that ain’t got no buissness being on the list.

        • davepower

          It isnt a perfect list but it will do

  • unscripted & flawless

    This list is pretty…uhm. I don’t know who Madison Eagles is, but if she’s had a big year, then congrats to her. Mickie James – okay. Natalya, I don’t disagree with. It’s been a pretty big year for her. I love Madison being in the Top 5. She is, in my opinion, the most solid heel in TNA. Now Beth Phoenix…like many before me have said, I don’t think she deserved that spot at all. She has not done anything on TV until the Divas of Doom storyline came up, and that was what? A month or two ago? Her spot, in my opinion, isn’t deserved. I DEFINITELY think Alicia Fox should be higher on the list and it really upsets me where she is. Alicia in the 40s? Gail, ACCOMPLISHMENT WISE, has not done anything in 2011 and she has not had any really good matches that weren’t on Superstars (which we know is because of time restraints, yeah yeah I know) …Eve has done nothing but have a boring Divas title reign and hug Kelly’s ass during her reign. As much as I despise Kelly Kelly, and I do, I will say her spot is solid and she deserves it (shocked!?) …she has been pushed above all others and she has a Divas title reign that (in my opinion) is a catastrophe because of her wrestling abilities, but at least they’re doing something with her. She should have been higher than Beth, but not higher on the list..Beth should have just been lower. So yeah that’s my real take on it. VERY upset about Beth and Alicia’s positions. Beth shoulda been lower, Alicia higher. Proud of AJ making it on! Congrats to her and Brie Bella’s spot seems solid. I won’t get into ODB’s spot because to be honest when she wasn’t in TNA, idk what the fuck she was doing. She coulda held 8 titles, I have no idea. I don’t comment on Indy’s people cause I don’t know Indy’s people so congrats to them all. Hopefully Madison will get some mainstream coverage in either TNA or WWE because if she’s good enough for the #1 position, she must be solid. :)

  • http://twin-magic.tumblr.com TwinMagic

    Decent list. Nikki Bella should have been on the list, and Brie should have been ranked higher than Kelly Kelly. They put a lot of independent wrestlers in the list, which is a good thing! I’m surprised I didn’t see Britani Knight on the list, or maybe I just didn’t look close enough. The girl has had a great year!

    • laqisha

      knight works only in Europe. the list is based on united states.

      • BillyGP

        Knight works Shimmer also

        • davepower

          One set of tapings that’s it

        • laqisha

          well if mia yim and the others i mintioned earlier can’t make it then knight is out of luck :(

  • http://www.youtube.com/RingVixens Teri

    Why Alicia didn’t rank higher is beyond me.

  • A.E

    nice lest top three are well deserved.why is the heck velvet and serena are lower than kelly just because they didn’t slap someone on the butt or done stinkface to their opponent :\

    • Mikas

      I’m sure gyrating your crotch on the ring ropes while the camera men make a nice closeup off your ass fits the same category has a buttslap or a stinkface, dont you think?

      • A.E

        yeah but the difference is velvet is trying to look impressive in the ring in her matches while doing actual wrestling moves i am not a velvet fan but i am not a hater eitherbut i do admit she is ok in the rings while kelly do nothing but butt slap and stinkface

      • BillyGP

        No it different since it a entrance and not moves during a match

  • Melina&Mickie4ever!

    The Top 10 is Beautiful this year , Pure Skills ! I thought Layla should have been higher than Eve and Angelina she did have very great year better than both TBH , and Im suprised Michelle isnt on there .. but eh…

    • A.E

      michelle mcool didn’t do something impressive this year rather than ,pinned by snokie ,retired and get beaten by kharma ,the only something good she did was the tables match i am surprised that layla make it this year,even though i like her

      • Melina&Mickie4ever!

        What are you talking about Michelle had a great year. Fueding with Mickie , Melina , Beth , Natalya , Kelly Kelly and Wrestlemania that seems like alot to me and she has has some killer matches also

    • shannymac

      Yeah, I’m surprised Michelle didn’t at least rank. She really didn’t do all that much this year, but she still maintained a solid presence on TV and in the ring right up until she left.

      I also don’t really understand why Eve is so high. Nothing against her, but I would expect her to be so high. Her title reign wasn’t all that remarkable and she hasn’t done much besides be Kelly’s sidekick since.

      • JACKBLACK

        umm Eve was feuding with Fox and the Bellas and was pushed most of the year so she did alot and the angle with Kelly didn’t start til a few months ago so Kelly really shouldnt be that high considering her push didn’t start til June.

        • BillyGP

          Kelly push was on SD too teaming with Edge and what not.

    • http://www.diva-fiva.com samtherofl

      Michelle McCool unified the titles… Awful Year… Just AWFUL.

      • BillyGP

        she did i thought it was LAYCOOL as a team. McCool year might of started good but ended bad being pinned by Snookie at Mania and crushed by Kharma but she passed the torch to her friend so that should count right?

  • shannymac

    There are a few rankings that I’m seriously questioning, but that’s to be expected. Once you get out of the top ten (which is so solid, imo), the ranking start to get a lot more confusing and don’t really mean as much.

    • shannymac

      *doesn’t

  • laqisha

    I’m happy that 2 indy wrestlers took the top spots this year. but sdr, serena, j-havok, canadian ninjas, sassy stephie,britnney savage should’ve been higher. what the heel is maryse, brittney force, Tina San Antonio, melissa coats doing here??? “anyone help me :/” and for some dump reason they added Kacee Carlisle O.o they shouldv’e been replaced by athena, mia yim, 5 stars amanda fox, jackie moore, haiely hatred and amy lee obviously they had better year. maybe pwi goes through every single promotion in usa and picks their top female talent and add them into the list thats how i see it.

  • Jhonmarco

    Much better list than previous ones. Nice to see indy women in the top spots. Seeing Kelly ranked at 15 is a bit surprising but its a fine spot for her. I was looking for Athena or Mia Yim to make this list. And Hamada? As much as I LOVE this woman, isn’t this for women who only work US shows? Hamada has only done Shimmer so that’s really weird, fine list though overall.

  • http://twitter.com/tjei012 TJÉ TC

    I’m not familiar with the Indie wrestlers, so here’s my top 10 list:
    SERENA
    MICKIE JAMES
    LAYLA
    WINTER
    AJ
    KHARMA
    KAITLYN
    MELINA
    GAIL KIM
    MADISON RAYNE

    lol don’t hate!

    • FrankNFurter

      What has AJ done since she’s been on the main roster? NOTHING! Has not impressed, not once. Neither has Kaitlyn, Gail, or Melina. In terms of prominence, competition, and feuds, the wrestlers I mentioned are expendable on any list.

      • http://Twitter.com/Just_Trevon Flybytre

        @franknfurter did you see the part where he or she said his or her list so that means his or her opinion damn let people think what the want.

        • FrankNFurter

          LOL, I wasn’t having a cow. It was serious question, I wanted to hear his/her reason why. And it’s sort of counterproductive to state “damn let people think what the want” and then berate me for my own opinion. Just saying.

      • BillyGP

        AJ has surprising victories plus they are counting her time in FCW also

        • FrankNFurter

          @BILLYGP That’s true she certainly has, but if you’re correct about PWI following FCW as well then why didn’t Naomi make the list considering she did in 2010? I mean she did hold the Diva’s championship from June to December and I believe she was undefeated in singles competition during her reign as well. And she also remains the longest reigning FCW Diva’s champion since it’s inception.

          I suppose it’s the main roster spot that inevitably got her the spot.

      • http://twitter.com/tjei012 TJÉ TC

        OOPS! you’re right. I forgot Naomi and what about Aksana – being FCW’s Divas Champ and Queen at the same time?

    • davepower

      How many matches did Kharma wrestle this year? Dumb list

      • BillyGP

        from Aug 1010 to Aug 2011 so they must be counting before Kong signed with WWE.

    • Kaitlyn1fan

      You’re amazing! Kaitlyn ftw!

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/ElectricMVx ElectricMVx

    Great list this year, nice to see Natalya finally make the Top 10. Glad to see the indy girls dominated this year, Madison & Mercedes are definitely the most credibly contenders. People also need to realise this isnt based on actual skill, it’s based on kayfabe, matches won, championships, getting the upper hand in feuds etc.

    No McCool this year?

    • FrankNFurter

      Acutally it is based on skill/wrestling ability as well as other factors. So it’s really the woman’s balance of all aspects PWI is looking for.

      • http://www.youtube.com/user/ElectricMVx ElectricMVx

        Miz won the male one this year. I can lend some insight into why. The Miz did the following during the grading period (June’10-May’11):

        Six-month reign as WWE champion.Winning every title for which he was eligible (WWE, US, and Tag).Money In The Bank winner.Successful title defenses at Royal Rumble and WrestleMania main events.Pinfall victories over John Cena, Randy Orton, R-Truth, John Morrison, Daniel Bryan, and Jerry Lawler.

        I think the list is MOSTLY about kayfabe, with obviously some about skill, which is why even if a wrestler like Eve/Kelly Kelly/Velvet won a lot of matches they wouldnt make #1

      • http://www.youtube.com/user/ElectricMVx ElectricMVx

        Every year it’s the same thing with PWI. Their top wrestler/female wrestler always causes a stir within the wrestling community, if you ever read an article about PWI 500/50 read the comments everybody complains because there is always someone better than them that should have won solely because they were a better wrestler

    • http://www.youtube.com/user/ElectricMVx ElectricMVx

      Woah, let’s just leave you and your ignorant, racist self alone in your basement.

  • BethPinUpStrong

    The fact Beth isn’t in the top five is crap. I do agree with Natalya, Eagle and Mickie being up there, but that’s about it. And Cheerleader Melissa before her too? Crap
    And Katilyn may not be the best, but she deserved to be on this list

    • A.E

      NO NO NO and HELL NO kaitlyne aint a wrestler she is a model in training to become one why would you even say that she hasn’t done anything impressive yet rather than winning NXT so unless she do something hel no she dosn’t deserve to be in the ring.

      • A.E

        or the list.

        • WWFoverWWE

          people throw the word “deserve” around way too much. kaitlyn barely deserves to be in a WWE ring, and some think she should be on the list of best female wrestlers??? sorry but it doesn’t work that way, the girl has a long way to go

      • Kaitlyn1fan

        You don’t know wrestling at all you people. Kaitlyn > Every diva.

    • Kaledrina

      beth was injured for half the year and when she came back didn’t do much at all. she’s only been relevant for the last two months.. probably around the time the list was finalised. beth is in the right place.