SHINE 10 in Review: As the Title Tournament Takes Shape, is Valkyrie’s Dominance Coming to an End?

SHINE 10 ended in controversial fashion on Friday night, with a  failed sneak attack by Allysin Kay and subsequent suspension giving us the first sign of cracks in Valkyrie’s previously united and dominant front.

In the main event, Valkyrie leader Rain faced Angelina Love in a rematch from their SHINE Championship tournament qualifier at SHINE 9. Rain came out victorious last time thanks to the aid of her cohorts as ringside, so to level the playing field this time, her accomplices were banned from interfering in the match. It was a close affair, until out of nowhere Allysin Kay crept up and took out the secondary referee at ringside. While the in-ring referee was distracted, Kay then snuck into the ring and clobbered Love with a bat, allowing Rain to get the pinfall. However, SHINE Vice-President of Talent Relations Lexie Fyfe was less than impressed, ordering the match to be restarted, and suspending Kay for 90 days in the process. Love would not be cheated on the restart, hitting a huge Botox Injection to pick up the victory and avenge her previous loss.

In what was certainly Valkyrie’s least successful show to date, Kay’s Made in Sin partner Taylor Made also came up short, being pinned in a good match against Leva Bates dressed as Mad Max (not Cher, as I embarrassingly thought). Earlier on, Kay herself had been victorious against Nikki Roxx in a solid qualifying match which ultimately was all for nought, as her suspension means she will be unable to compete in the tournament. Her replacement has not been chosen, but Roxx will certainly feel deserving of another shot after this. Valkyrie’s only consolation came from Ivelisse, who was up against the debuting veteran Amber O’Neal. Ivelisse picked up the win in a fine contest, pinning O’Neal with a Disdain, and ensuring that Valkyrie’s credibility remains somewhat intact.

The match of the night came from Mia Yim and Mercedes Martinez, who faced off in qualifying action. In a thrilling and hard-fought war of attrition, it was Yim who would grab the surprise victory, countering Martinez’s Fisherman Buster into an inside cradle to pull off a massive upset and advance to the championship tournament at SHINE 11.  Meanwhile, the final tournament place was won by Santana, who wowed the audience with her usual incredible displays of athleticism, defeating Kimberly in a high-octane bout to keep her title aspirations alive and pile more misery onto a Kimberly who has had her fair share of misfortune in recent months.

Jessicka Havok had already qualified for the tournament back at SHINE 9, but after a war of words on Twitter with Canadian Ninja Portia Perez, decided to put her spot on the line in an attempt to prove who the better woman is. Perez was her usual playful self, keeping Havok on her toes with her unorthodox style before finally succumbing to the Air Raid Crash, meaning Havok’s place in the tournament remains safe. Finally, the team of Sassy Stephie, Jessie Belle and Sojo Bolt defeated Heidi Lovelace, Luscious Latasha and Solo Darling in a fun six-woman tag match that did well to break up the tournament action and give some exposure to up-and-coming talents on the SHINE roster. The rookie Solo Darling particularly impressed, and seeing Stephie pick up the victory for her team was a rare and welcome surprise – more of that please!

Ten shows and almost a year in, SHINE continues to have the most consistent product in women’s wrestling today. The eight matches were all top-quality, and woven together with straightforward but intelligent and positive booking that leaves us asking all the right questions. One gripe I had with last month’s show was the length – at over three hours long, it finished as dawn was breaking where I live – and this was corrected this time round, with SHINE 10 clocking in at a little over two hours. Away from the action, Daffney‘s new managerial role, which saw her scouting each match meticulously at ringside, adds a nice touch of speculation towards future alliances and rivalries, and her successor as ring announcer Chasity Taylor did an excellent job on her first night. Meanwhile, Dave Prazak was a welcome asset to the commentary table, his extensive wrestling knowledge providing a colourful verbal backdrop to the action.

The title tournament lineup is complete save for one, and judging by the quality of the talent we look set to see some sensational matches, with all of the seven current qualifiers in with a serious chance of victory. The tournament will take place in its entirety on July 12th at SHINE 11, and whoever is crowned champion that night will have the privilege – and responsibility – of being the face of the most exciting women’s wrestling promotion right now.

Indies Reviewer & News Reporter - Read Profile
  • DJ8946

    I watched & it was a great show. I thought Leva was dressed as Cher too! I would love to Audrey Marie/ Ashley Miller in the rookie part of the show even if she loses her 1st couple of matches.


      But she cant wrestle…

      • Looking Glass

        Says the person sat behind a keyboard.

      • Raekon

        I guess you are one of these persons that are just jumping into threads to say people can’t wrestle?

        How about you show us how good you can wrestle before you badmouth others?

        • charovnica

          Considering how big of hypocrites you people are I’d say leave the guy/girl alone.Noone is saying anything while you bash Cena or Kelly for the same thing.

      • Getdownwithachola

        Excuse me….When us fans say “He/She can’t wrestle” we are not comparing their skills to our skills I mean I can totally beat the shit out of the Bellas because I trained in martial arts and much bigger than the two, but at wrestling skills they are better than me at the moment…..In-fact we don’t mean it literally, I’m sure Audery knows whats a headlock is, but what @DIVAKO did he was comparing her to maybe Rain or Jessicka Havok.

  • Number One

    SHINE 10 was a great show! I think that vacant spot will most likely go to Angelina Love, mainly because she beat Rain and she was the near victim of a screw-job finish. I see Leva Bates turning heel at SHINE 11. She still had that intense and vicious demeanor on Friday, that she had in her thrilling rivalry against Kimberly. I think that it would lead to Leva becoming a villainess at July’s show. As for who I think will win, I can’t say. Because Rain’s retiring in a few months, I would think they’d have her as the first champion and then have Angelina or another babyface knock her off. Either way, I can’t wait for SHINE 11!

    • Cyndi

      i liked all the matches but the main event i felt the Havoc/Perez match should’ve been the main event since it had more at stake then the Rain/Love match

    • Raekon

      Angelina already lost her qualifier though and there are other Girls on the roster that didn’t participated at all so I rather hope that one of them is getting a chance instead of one of the Girls that already lost their bouts.

  • pumped up kicks

    I think they are gonna give the spot to Kong or Jazz… at least I hope they do that!

    • GailKim95

      but Jazz already has a spot because she beat Ivelisse. I want them to do a last chance battle royal Like Pro Wrestling: EVE did once. All the losers of the qualifiers are involved and someone like Angelina wins

      • ZPZA

        I can see this happening honestly. It gives more spots for the other girls rather than just the 7 in the tournament brackets.

    • wl75

      Jazz is already qualified (she beat Ivelisse at Shine 9)..

  • Raekon

    I must admit that I liked some of the previous Shows more.
    However, it was still a great Show that I enjoyed a lot and I can’t wait for SHINE 11. :)

    The match of the night for me was Kimberly vs Santana.
    Kimberly was hilarious and at the same time hard hitting and strong.
    Santana was her usual self so there isn’t much to add to it. ^_^

    Loved having Amber O Neil on SHINE and her match against Ivelisse was good.

    The six womens bout was refreshing and the girls involved were all great.

    Was nice to see that Solo Darling had stepped up her game because she was a bit off in her first match at SHINE.

    I love how SHINE always has something suprising and unpredictable going on in every Show. :)

    It was great to see the DQ of Ak47 (for whatever reason she can’t be there at SHINE 11) be handled that way and I can’t wait to see who will take her spot in the tournament.

    Hopefully a battle royal between Girls that didn’t participate in the qualifiers yet, in which the winner earns the spot.