Snap Judgment: Do You Prefer Mickie James as a Heel or a Babyface?

We’re bringing back our old Snap Judgment feature to ask you questions and get a gut answer.

Every so often, we’ll ask a simple question, and you’ll vote in the poll. Remember: go with your gut. We want to know what you really think. Hey, it’s called Snap Judgment for a reason!

Right now, as Mickie James is in the middle of a full-on heel turn, we’re wondering: Do you prefer Mickie as bad or good? We’re talking TNA heel Mickie, not WWE “psycho” heel Mickie.

Quick, vote in the poll below and tell us what you picked in the comments!

Editor in Chief - Read Profile
  •!/JillianHallTNA TNAknockoutJillianHall

    LOL loving this Snap Judgment thing! :D What’s wrong with getting a little bit dirty, huh? :P

  • MrJCena

    Love a bad guy in wrestling they have more time to shine and create a character which is awesome

  • Monkey Tennis

    It’s not a surprise to see the votes for heel-Mickie winning. In general, it’s usually a more interesting role for any wrestler and Mickie’s been a face for so long that naturally people are happy to see her turn and be given a little bit more to do.

    However, looking at it PURELY from the perspective of Mickie as a wrestler, I think she suits the face role more. She just comes across more naturally that way. Indeed, even when she was supposed to be the heel in her debuting storyline with Trish all those years ago, she split the crowd cos she’s just so inherently likeable!

  • Divafan0118

    Babyface, just because she wrestles better

  • let the pigeons loose 12

    Love Mickie as both ! She’s a talented women I think all KO’s are great in that way, that they can pull of heel and face.

    P.S does any one else love that picture Velvet is just like DA HELL

  • MickieJamesluvslave

    I prefer her as a babyface but have no problem with her being a heel. I think her personality fits being face better but her character needed refreshing

  • divaindemise

    Mickie radiates personality but I would like to see this heel character develop more before casting judgement on which role she suits better. I do think she deserves props for remaining a consistently popular and resilient babyface, though.

  • BarbieBlank

    Of course her heel charecter will win because most if us got tired of seeing her play the good guy


      Who is your photo of?

      •!/JillianHallTNA TNAknockoutJillianHall

        Rihanna, obviously!

      •!/JillianHallTNA TNAknockoutJillianHall

        but our avatars are better. We have JILLIAN!! :’D

  • Dave Muscarella

    Mickie’s heel run in WWE was fantastic. The build to the heel turn was so well done and it resulted in a bunch of good matches with Trish. Mickie does pyscho better than most. When she’s in a good program with someone, heel Mickie is the best Mickie.

  • StraightEdgeCRF

    I don’t care.I love Mickie whether she’s a babyface or a heel.

  • kio3j2

    I fell in love with her when she was a heel feuding with Trish, so yea, but she could play any role well.

  • Bikini model destroyer

    Only in TNA I prefer her to be a face because as a heel now she is going to be booked like a fool losing clean to every face knockout and shit.

    Also who ever created the names “face” “heel” should get punched in the face. I’m sorry but that sounds really stupid, why can’t you just call them “Hero” “Villan”???

    • MickieJamesluvslave

      But before this turn, she was losing cleanly in almost every match she was in. I remember commenting how much I hated her losing all the time

      • Bikini model destroyer

        Not really, Maybe she did loss a bit but she was allowed to utilize her wrestling moves, now with this turn she is gonna be restricted to only dirty tactics. So my point is if you guys are real wrestling fans you would want to see her as a face. Sorry I watch wrestling to see cool wrestling moves.

  • jcarcano12

    I like her in both role but baby face is better

  • redsandman99

    She was brilliant as the psycho heel in WWE and she’s so far been brilliant with this progressing heel turn in TNA. She’s also great at being a face though since she’s naturally likeable. It makes it too hard to decide for me.

  • Ambrose-DivaFan

    I can’t choose, she is an awesome face, and incredible heel, she plays both amazing!!

  • Sarah Connor

    i love her more as a babyface and the piggy jams storyline confirmed that.

    • Sarah Connor

      *piggy james

  • Lil’Homie

    In TNA I prefer her face. In WWE however I prefer her heel.

  • charovnica

    It really is an unfair question imo.I mean she hasn’t been a heel since the end of 2006.That’s 7 years as a babyface.Also she was a psycho heel before and we don’t know how she’ll do as a normal bitchy one.I kind of think though that it’s time for a change in her character,so I’m not against her heel turn.I just can’t answer the question,cause she was a very successful face.

    • Monkey Tennis

      Yeah, the question as asked is flawed. Technically Mickie hasn’t fully turned yet, and yet DD are asking if we prefer her in a role that we haven’t completely seen as yet (particularly as the question makes a point to say it’s NOT talking about WWE Mickie).

      Essentially what the question is really asking (and certainly the question most people here are answering) is “Are you happy that Mickie is turning heel right now?”

      And I think most people would say the answer to THAT question is yes.

  • art

    She does both really well but i have to say i like her heel….

  • notorious

    Very used to her as a babyfaxe since that was her whole career. She is a great heel but it has to be at a good time and be given a good build.

  • jim462

    Mickie is my favorite knockout face or heel. But I prefer her as a heel shes more interesting as a evil crazy rulebreakerI hope she goes total heel like in her WWE days

  • Jakespearit

    Heel. It would be so awesome if her and Tara teamed to form like a psychotic faction, it would be really interesting!

  • ahlanthony

    For me, Mickie’s personality screams heel. She looks very heelish and she’s hella good at being bad!

    P.S. She looks great. I can tell she’s been seriously working out.

  • aldo

    Heel, but I think it’s just because she has been heel for so many years. She plays the babyface role perfectly though.

    • aldo

      “…it’s just because she has been FACE for so many years.”

  • bikini kill

    I think Mickie is best as a heel that thinks she’s a face. Thats why she’s the ultimate tweener. In her feud with Trish she was supposed to be the heel, but she was too crazy to know the audience wasn’t supposed to like her- so she made them love her by acting face towards the crowd and heel to her opponents. Thats the genius of Mickie James, and I think she should do the same thing in TNA- but a little dirtier in the ring. A heel that still loves the audience, but hates her face opponents.