Note: Scorekeeping started with NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia in January.
| Team Member | Wins | Losses | Most Recent Win |
| Alex | 12 | 9 | Money in the Bank |
| Charley | 14 | 5 | Money in the Bank |
| Josue | 16 | 5 | Money in the Bank |
| Matthew H | 9 | 6 | TakeOver: Chicago II |
| Matthew M | 10 | 5 | Backlash |
| Michael | 5 | 7 | Money in the Bank |
| Nick W | 10 | 7 | Money in the Bank |
| Stephanie | 12 | 9 | Money in the Bank |