Note: Scorekeeping started with NXT TakeOver: San Antonio in January.
| Team Member | Wins | Losses | Most Recent Win |
| Abir | 18 | 19 | Clash of Champions |
| Alex | 21 | 17 | Clash of Champions |
| Candace | 9 | 6 | TLC |
| Josue | 20 | 18 | Clash of Champions |
| Matthew | 17 | 14 | TLC |
| Rhys | 7 | – | Survivor Series |
| Stephanie | 21 | 11 | Clash of Champions |