Who is Wrestling’s Best Mean Girl? Round 1: Dawn Marie vs. Stacy Keibler

At its root, wrestling has always been about good vs evil, bad guys vs good guys — or in our case, bad girls vs good girls.

In a brand new feature at Diva Dirt, we want you to help us pick wrestling’s best mean girl. Now, there is a clear distinction between a mean girl and your regular “heel”. When we say “mean girl” we refer to the women in wrestling who were feisty, vindictive, acid-tongued and bitchy! They may not necessarily be the toughest, or the baddest, but they certainly had tons of personality.

Based on your nominations, we picked the 16 most mentioned women in wrestling to advance to our knock-out bracket tournament. Keep your eyes peeled over the next few weeks as you will be asked to vote between some of wrestling’s best mean girls and help us whittle it down from just 16 to one!

- To see the full tournament brackets click here (Note: All pairings drawn at random.)

Round 1: Seduction played a big part in the careers of Dawn Marie and Stacy Keibler, but in very different ways: Dawn Marie famously seduced Torrie Wilson‘s father to his death bed (literally) while attempting to seduce Torrie herself. Stacy showed cunning and found power in the men she associated herself with, from David Flair to Vince McMahon, and didn’t hesitate to use these men against her fellow Divas. So, which is meaner: seduction as revenge, or seduction for power?

It’s a tough choice, but the vote is entirely down to you!

Vote below:


MORE ROUND 1 POLLS: The Beautiful People vs Maxine | Sable vs Trish Stratus | Ivory vs. Melina | Maryse vs. Vince’s Devils

Who did you vote for? Tell us in the comments and on Twitter by sending a message to @divadirt!

Editor in Chief - Read Profile

    mmmmmmm ……. I’m not a fan of these two but my vote is for Dawn because …. she kills a person!! XD

  • bjorn448

    I think its Stacy Keibler.

  • lucky1now

    Honestly don’t care for either one but dawn had that big fued with torrie it lasted a pretty long time
    I don’t think sttacy had anything that bad or long

  • redsandman99

    Dawn all the way for me. She pretty much tortured Torrie and had her moments with Jackie and Michelle McCool as well.

  • http://www.gailkimsource.com Danni

    Dawn Marie.

  • King of Mean

    obviously Dawn Marie, her rivalry against Torrie Wilson showed everybody that she is one of the biggest bad girl in WWE!

  • YouCanLookButYouCan’tTouch

    I love Stacy Keibler,but my vote goes to Dawn Marie.Her look and attitude just screamed Mean Girl.

  • http://ashmultimedia.wordpress.com melon2617

    Dawn Marie for sure!

    Dawn was bad to her very core; seducing Al Wilson, having an affair with Charlie Haas, seducing Torrie Wilson and doing whatever it took to get ahead. Stacy always looked lost in her “bad” roles and never looked like she was comfortable in them.

  • WhalenX12

    Definitely Dawn Marie ! Especially with the whole Torrie Wilson feud.

  • http://twitter.com/RyanRoman0 Ryan

    Neither was a “mean girl”. Dawn and Stacey were sexy seducing hot sluts!! (character wise) ;D
    Usually we know Dawn as an ass kicking diva cat fight machine with her hard fore arm shots and hair snapmares haha
    But she had one amazing match against Nidia on Velocity that makes me think Dawn was Women’s championship materia, plus she had a banging body back then and that sexy smirk…but she let herself go
    Same with Stacey vs Jillian Hall, Stacey was legit. plus that sexy walk like none Other and that pretty face!!
    As far as mean girl goes, I guess Stacey…
    She could totally pull off some bimbo snobby mean girl more than dawn lol
    Wait! Those two had a mini confrontation o Smackdown Stacey was calling dawn desperate for showing around her big boobs, dawn just response that she’s maybe just jealous because Daen had “something” Stacey didn’t lol… Big Boobs XD

  • mpezza

    Easily Dawn.. she was awesome.

  • http://www.youtube.com/jillfan1 Jillfan1

    DAWMN MARIE FOR sure tormenting , Torrie, The diva search girls I grew up watching her and oh baby i was intimidated by her character she played it so well would have liked to see her as champ tons of charisma

  • MattyM

    Dawn Marie from her feud with Torrie to Miss.Jackie to Michelle McCool Joy Giovanni & Lauren Jones

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/dsanchez96?feature=mhum sanchezdiego96

    Dawn. Marrying Torrie’s dad and being all skanky in front of her with him was a bitch move. She was the first female character I really hated. But I love her now!

  • kreece

    I love Stacy, she was more of a seductive hottie (aksanas current role so it seems) when she was a heel, rather than a mean girl. I can only really remember her face days. But dawn was THE ulitmate bitch playing the wicked step mother role

  • LaylaElFan

    I would go for Dawn Marie because of the whole Torrie Wilson storyline which lasted like a year.

  • http://purple-fusions.net PurpleFusions

    Has to be Dawn Marie…from her ECW days to the WWE, she’s been a great mean girl…

  • MickieJamesluvslave

    This one is easy for me: Dawn marie. Fromher ECW days to her tormeting Torrie

  • TheLadySamantha

    Stacy played such an awkward heel. Vote goes to Dawn Marie.


    Dwan, obviously!!!!! who can forget the storyline with torrie and her father???

  • http://Www.Facebook.com/StuartWilliamMcKay StuartWilliamMckay

    Stacy was heel ? Really ? I’m a Dawn fan anyhow so this round should go to her !

  • Jcott3

    Sorry, gotta go with Dawn Marie by default. Stacy did very little in her career to be a mean girl other than a few promos she did with Torrie during the Invasion.

  • Crazy_J

    I don’t see how you could vote for Stacy on this one considering I don’t remember her doing much heel type things, except for what someone else already mentioned in the invasion angle. Even then though she was getting cheered. Dawn was one of those bad girls all around, just her sex appeal made her seem bad lol, loved her!

  • Essex Boy

    Dawn Marie Bitch!

  • http://www.twitter.com/Diva_Fan_4_Life DivaFan4Life

    I love them both but i’d go with stacy because even when she was face, she somehow ended up being a tweener/heel and she was good at being a heel when it came to being a valet or even her character with vince taking control over his power, Dawn marie i always felt would’ve been the best babyface for smackdown but that never happened :/